Teachers’ Union Releases Alternative Facilities Plan

The 15,000 member Philadelphia Federation of Teachers has released its “Facilities Action Plan”, a detailed alternative to the school district’s Facilities Master Plan. The PFT plan includes no school closings. The cost of the PFT plan would be considerably less than the district’s ten-year, $3 billion plan, approved by the Board of Education last April. The union’s plan would spend just $75 million of the district’s existing operating budget for repairs and upgrades, including air conditioning. The PFT report characterizes the district’s plan as “neither a comprehensive educational facilities master plan nor a plan that can deliver on even the limited promises it makes.”

Most of the district’s plan relies on funding from government and philanthropic sources, none of which has been procured or even promised. Board Member Whitney Jones, at a recent meeting, asked Superintendent Tony Watlington Sr. to explain how the facilities plan could be implemented with ⅔ of the funding still unaccounted for. Watlington did not dispute that. He urged those present to “go lobby” for the funds. 

The major aim of the PFT plan is to “reverse…two negative trends at once: the ongoing deterioration of our school buildings and the exodus of students and staff from district schools.”

At a press conference Wednesday, PFT President Arthur Steinberg, surrounded by teachers and staff from the 17 schools slated for closure, called on the board to amend its current plan to include provisions of the union’s plan. Steinberg called on Mayor Cherelle Parker, who appoints all nine members of the school board, to “intervene” in the facilities process. Councilmembers Nina Ahmad, Jamie Gauthier and Rue Landau stood with Steinberg in support of the PFT plan. Steinberg pointed out that virtually “100%” of the parents, educators and students have expressed opposition to closing any neighborhood schools. 

Jerry Roseman, the PFT’s longtime director of environmental services, stated that the union’s plan aims to make every school “clean, comfortable, dry, and safe.” Roseman disputed the district’s data on building capacity at many schools. He also asked why the district intends to send students from closing schools to “receiving schools” that are still in disrepair. 

Teachers from the closing schools spoke about the successes of their schools and pointed out the incorrect data in the district’s reports about schools’ enrollment and building capacity. Lankenau High School teacher Jonathan Hoffmeier asked, “Where is the honor in closing successful schools?” In recent years, Lankenau has achieved a100% graduation rate. “Our schools are not real estate opportunities”, Hoffmeier said. Harding Middle School teacher Jana Pugsley said that Harding’s enrollment has already fallen as a result of being targeted for closure and the district’s failure to make necessary repairs at the Frankford school. Parkway Northwest High School for Peace and Justice teacher Farris Carter said that district reports have posted inaccurate building scores for the school. 

The PFT will be issuing an addendum to their plan in coming weeks.

Our reporters sit through hours of city council meetings, dig through piles of documents, and ask tough questions other media overlook. Because we’re committed to addressing Philadelphia’s poverty crisis — and challenging those who sustain it. If you think this work is important too, please support our journalism.

We’re counting on readers like you.

We monitor Philly's local halls of power to bring you the news you need to know.

SCHOOLS CLOSING,

COSTS CLIMBING?

This site uses cookies to provide you with a great user experience. By continuing to use this website, you consent to the use of cookies in accordance with our privacy policy.